The emergence of digital currencies has sparked a global transformation in financial systems, challenging long-standing economic theories and reshaping how we understand money, organizations, and value. Digital Currency Economic Analysis by Yao Qian and Chen Hua offers a comprehensive exploration of this shift, combining technical insights with rigorous economic frameworks to assess both private and central bank digital currencies (CBDCs). This book not only identifies critical gaps in modern economic theory but also proposes structured solutions grounded in real-world applications.
The Four Silences of Modern Economic Theory
Digital currencies have exposed limitations in traditional economic thinking. Four core areas—monetary theory, organizational behavior, asset pricing, and fiat currency models—are struggling to keep pace with technological innovation.
Monetary Theory at a Crossroads
Bitcoin’s decentralized architecture aligns closely with Carl Menger’s theory of spontaneous monetary order, where money emerges organically from social consensus rather than state decree. Proponents argue that cryptocurrencies fulfill this vision by using cryptography, peer-to-peer networks, and consensus algorithms to establish trust without central authority. This appeals strongly to libertarian ideals, fueling hopes of replacing government-issued money.
But is consensus alone sufficient for a functional currency? While digital assets like Bitcoin reflect collective belief, they lack the universal acceptability, stability, and legal backing that define modern fiat systems. Traditional theories—whether metallist, chartalist, or privatization-based—are inadequate in explaining this new paradigm. The evolution from barter to commodity money, then to credit and now digital forms, demands a fresh theoretical foundation.
👉 Discover how digital currencies are redefining the future of money.
Organizational Behavior Reimagined
Blockchain technology challenges conventional corporate structures. Decentralized networks operate without boards, hierarchies, or centralized management. Instead, they rely on algorithmic governance—a form of "organizationless organization" driven by code rather than command.
This raises profound questions for organizational economics:
- How do proof-of-work (PoW) and proof-of-stake (PoS) mechanisms create incentive-compatible environments?
- What role does distributed ledger technology (DLT) play in reshaping accounting standards and corporate governance?
- Can decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms replicate the efficiency of traditional financial intermediaries?
Moreover, the rise of algorithm-driven economies calls for new models to explain coordination beyond market prices. As artificial intelligence and big data advance, concerns grow about whether algorithmic control could mimic central planning. A robust theoretical framework is needed to analyze the boundaries between markets, firms, and code-based systems.
Asset Pricing in Uncharted Territory
Valuing cryptocurrencies remains one of the most contentious issues in finance. In 2017, Bitcoin’s surge sparked debate: Was it driven by utility, scarcity, speculation, or ideological appeal?
Unlike stocks or bonds, crypto assets often lack cash flows, making traditional valuation methods like discounted cash flow (DCF) difficult to apply. Some classify tokens as commodities; others see them as securities or digital property. Hybrid designs—such as stablecoins—further complicate classification.
Additionally:
- Many tokens are priced and traded in other cryptos (e.g., Ethereum-based tokens quoted in ETH), introducing volatility dependencies.
- Inter-token ecosystems create symbiotic value relationships that resist conventional modeling.
- Speculative demand often overshadows fundamental use cases.
These complexities reveal a significant gap in asset pricing theory. New methodologies must account for network effects, protocol utility, and behavioral dynamics unique to blockchain ecosystems.
The Evolving Role of Fiat Currency
As private digital currencies gain traction, central banks are accelerating research into CBDCs. Unlike decentralized alternatives, CBDCs aim to digitize sovereign money while preserving monetary sovereignty and financial stability.
Key design questions include:
- Should CBDCs be account-based or token-based?
- Centralized, decentralized, or hybrid infrastructure?
- One-tier (direct central bank access) or two-tier (intermediated through commercial banks)?
More importantly, CBDCs represent more than a technical upgrade—they could transform payment systems, monetary policy transmission, and financial inclusion. However, no country has fully implemented a CBDC yet, leaving economic impacts largely theoretical. Rigorous modeling and pilot testing are essential before large-scale deployment.
Bridging Theory and Practice: A Framework for Digital Currency Research
Rather than rejecting established economics, Digital Currency Economic Analysis advocates for integration. The authors propose a systematic approach to studying both private and public digital currencies within existing theoretical frameworks.
Microeconomic Foundations
Using game theory, the book analyzes how blockchain consensus mechanisms align individual incentives with network security. For example:
- PoW rewards miners for validating blocks, creating competition that secures the ledger.
- PoS aligns validators’ interests with long-term network health by staking their own holdings.
This leads to what some call "crypto-economics"—the study of incentive structures in decentralized protocols.
Governance and Contractual Design
The book applies contract economics to examine agency problems in blockchain ecosystems. Without formal institutions, governance relies on:
- On-chain mechanisms (e.g., voting protocols)
- Off-chain coordination (e.g., developer communities)
- Formal rules encoded in smart contracts
- Informal norms and community consensus
For initial coin offerings (ICOs), the authors propose regulatory frameworks tailored to token types—security tokens versus utility tokens—balancing innovation with investor protection.
👉 Explore how next-generation financial systems are being built today.
Mid-Level Analysis: DLT and Financial Markets
Distributed ledgers differ fundamentally from traditional accounting systems:
- Immutability reduces fraud risk
- Transparency enhances auditability
- Decentralization minimizes single points of failure
In capital markets, DLT enables decentralized trading platforms that eliminate intermediaries. The book compares these models with centralized exchanges across dimensions like speed, cost, privacy, and regulatory compliance.
Valuation Methodologies for Crypto Assets
The authors introduce five valuation approaches:
- Cost-based pricing – based on mining expenses
- Monetary pricing – treating crypto as digital cash
- Equity-style valuation – for protocol tokens with revenue-sharing features
- Option pricing – valuing network growth potential
- Arbitrage-free pricing – ensuring consistency across markets
They also analyze derivatives like Bitcoin futures and ETFs, highlighting tensions between market innovation and regulatory oversight.
Toward a Central Bank Digital Currency Framework
The latter half of the book focuses on CBDC design. Drawing on the "money flower" model, it defines key attributes: issuer (central bank), technology (digital), form (token or account), and accessibility (wholesale or retail).
A central contribution is the proposed "one currency, two libraries, three centers" architecture:
- One digital currency issued by the central bank
- Two repositories: issuance库 and circulation库
- Three core systems: registration, verification, and supervision
The authors advocate a two-tier operational model, where commercial banks distribute CBDCs under central bank oversight—preserving financial intermediation while enabling innovation.
Critically, they challenge the assumption that blockchain is necessary for CBDCs. Instead, they propose a "loosely coupled" approach: integrating distributed ledger technologies only where beneficial, avoiding unnecessary complexity.
Forward-Looking Policy Mechanisms
To enhance monetary policy effectiveness, the book introduces "forward-condition-triggered issuance"—a programmable mechanism where CBDC release responds automatically to economic indicators (e.g., inflation targets or employment thresholds). This could improve counter-cyclical adjustments and reduce policy lags.
An experimental AI-driven issuance model is also presented, simulating currency投放 via foreign exchange interventions using machine learning algorithms.
Macroeconomic Impact Assessment
Using a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model calibrated to China’s economy, the authors simulate CBDC effects across four sectors: households, firms, banks, and the central bank. Findings suggest:
- Limited disruption to existing financial intermediaries
- Improved payment efficiency
- Enhanced monetary policy precision
- Positive overall welfare outcomes
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can Bitcoin replace traditional money?
A: While Bitcoin functions as a store of value for some, its volatility and scalability constraints limit its use as a medium of exchange or unit of account—key functions of money.
Q: Are CBDCs the same as cryptocurrencies?
A: No. CBDCs are state-backed digital currencies with centralized control; most cryptocurrencies are decentralized and not legal tender.
Q: Will digital currencies eliminate banks?
A: Unlikely. Even with CBDCs, financial intermediation will remain vital for credit assessment and maturity transformation.
Q: How do smart contracts relate to economic theory?
A: They automate contractual enforcement using code, reducing transaction costs—aligning closely with Coasean theories of the firm.
Q: Is decentralized finance (DeFi) sustainable?
A: It shows promise but faces challenges in regulation, security, and systemic risk management.
Q: What’s the biggest risk of CBDCs?
A: Financial disintermediation during crises—if users rapidly shift deposits to risk-free CBDCs, bank lending could contract sharply.
👉 Stay ahead of the curve in the evolving world of digital finance.
Conclusion
Digital Currency Economic Analysis provides a foundational framework for understanding the economic implications of digital currencies. By bridging theory and practice, it helps policymakers, academics, and industry leaders navigate this transformative era—not by discarding old models, but by extending them to meet new realities. As digital money evolves from concept to reality, such rigorous analysis will be indispensable.